Edinburgh Ad Ban Draws Industry Criticism

Industry bodies criticize Edinburgh's ban on polluting ads, raising concerns over revenue loss and environmental impact.

A Controversial Move by Edinburgh Council

Edinburgh Council has stirred significant debate with its recent decision to ban advertisements from several polluting categories on its outdoor advertising estate. The ban, which excludes ads for airlines, fossil fuel companies, petrol cars, SUVs, cruise holidays, and arms manufacturers, has been met with criticism from industry bodies such as the Advertising Association and Outsmart, the trade body for outdoor advertising.

Details of the Ban

The council's decision, approved by a 15-2 vote, will apply only to council-owned sites and is set to become mandatory with the next contract for selling advertising space in 2030. Currently, JCDecaux holds the contract, which was established in 2014 and extended for five additional years. Although the council has invited JCDecaux to voluntarily implement the ban, the company has declined to comment on the matter.

Financial Concerns

Industry bodies have expressed concerns primarily about the potential financial implications of the ban. Tim Lumb, director of Outsmart, emphasized the crucial role out-of-home advertising plays in generating revenue for public services. He highlighted Edinburgh’s significant £150 million budget shortfall, arguing that the ban could exacerbate the city’s financial woes.

“Out-of-home advertising is an important revenue stream for councils, funding public infrastructure like bus shelters, telephony, defibrillators, as well as helping the public purse through rents, revenue-share agreements, and business rates. In fact, 46% of spend in out-of-home advertising goes back into the economy,” Lumb stated.

Similarly, a spokesperson for the Advertising Association pointed out that reducing advertising revenue would negatively impact public services and economic activity. They also noted that the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) ensures all advertising messaging, including environmental claims, are "legal, decent, honest, and truthful."

Environmental and Ethical Dimensions

Despite the financial criticisms, proponents of the ban, including the campaign group Adfree Cities, argue that it is a necessary step towards combating climate change. Robbie Gillett from Adfree Cities praised Edinburgh Council's decision, calling it a world-leading climate policy.

“Our daily exposure to adverts encouraging us to buy more and more polluting products runs in contradiction to the urgent need to decarbonise our economy. Edinburgh Council has taken an important step to resolve that contradiction,” Gillett said.

Scottish Greens councillor Ben Parker, who spearheaded the policy, echoed these sentiments. “We’re pleased the council has taken a lead on the issue of fossil-free advertising and sponsorship. It’s just basic common sense that if the council is serious about its commitment to climate justice, we cannot allow council advertising space to be used to promote fossil fuel companies,” Parker remarked.

Broader Implications and Industry Response

Edinburgh is not the first UK city to enact such a ban; it follows the lead of cities like Sheffield and Liverpool and regions such as Somerset and Cambridgeshire. The trend is driven by groups like Adfree Cities, which aim to reduce public exposure to harmful advertisements.

However, some industry leaders argue that the ban is misguided. Mike Hawes, chief executive of the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, criticized the restrictions as poorly conceived and counterproductive, particularly concerning SUV advertisements.

“Industry wants to see all cities, including Edinburgh, meet their environmental targets and continues to invest in ever more advanced technology to improve air quality and address climate change. These advertising restrictions, however, are poorly conceived and will only cause confusion given the term ‘SUV’ has no official definition and can encompass vehicles of all sizes,” Hawes commented.

Looking Forward

As Edinburgh moves forward with this policy, the city sets a precedent that may influence other councils across the UK. The long-term impact on both environmental efforts and public service funding remains to be seen, but the debate highlights the complex interplay between financial realities and the urgent need for climate action.

With Edinburgh attracting millions of tourists annually and housing a population of over 500,000, the decisions made by its council could have far-reaching implications for how cities balance economic and environmental priorities in the future.

Discover the Latest Blogs on Outdoor Advertising in Canada

Read More

Read More

Read More

Read More

Read More

Read More

Read More

Read More

Read More

Read More

Read More

Read More

Read More

Read More

Read More

Read More